Gold became Rs18,900 a tola cheaper in two days, yet a Karachi buyer can still pay up to Rs30,000 more than the official price. The All Pakistan Sarafa Gems and Jewellers Association set 24-karat gold at Rs376,336 a tola on Saturday, 21 November, down Rs3,500 in a day and Rs15,400 the day before. Dealers in Karachi are charging a premium of Rs10,000 to Rs30,000 a tola on gold bars, as shops run short of bars.
The board rate is not the shop price
The association rate is a benchmark. The shop price is what a buyer actually pays. Add the premium to Saturday’s board rate and a one-tola bar costs between Rs386,336 and Rs406,336. At the top end, a bar costs Rs7,400 more than the board rate of three days earlier, Rs398,936 on 18 November. That is a premium of about 2.7 to 8 percent.
This premium is not a making charge. This is extra money for the bar itself, because demand for physical bars is running ahead of supply. Association Vice President Hamza Shikarpuri confirmed a premium of Rs10,000 a tola is running, and said investors pay it in cash and wait a day or two for delivery of gold biscuits. A salesman in Hyderi Market, North Nazimabad, told Dawn: “We don’t have gold bars in our shops. We manage them through our sources.”
A week that took Rs34,600 off a tola
In the week ended Saturday, 21 November, 24-karat gold fell Rs34,600 a tola, from Rs410,936 on 14 November to Rs376,336, a drop of 8.42 percent. The rate moved from Rs408,936 on Tuesday to Rs376,336 on Saturday, with the biggest single-day fall, Rs15,400, on Friday. From Rs435,636 on 5 November, a tola is now Rs59,300 cheaper. Earlier this year the metal touched about Rs585,000 a tola, so the fall from that peak is now Rs208,664, or about 35.7 percent.
Silver fell harder. Its price dropped Rs743 a tola in the same week, from Rs5,343 to Rs4,600, a fall of 13.91 percent. Internationally, gold fell from $3,884 an ounce to $3,538, down 8.91 percent in a week, and silver fell from $48.65 to $41.22, down 15.27 percent. Reuters called it gold’s worst week in eight months. No new rate was issued on Sunday, so Saturday’s rate still stands.
Why the world price fell
The fall came from abroad, not from the rupee. The dollar stayed near Rs276, so the local drop tracks the world price almost exactly. Traders blame a stronger US dollar and growing expectations that the US Federal Reserve will raise interest rates in December. Reuters reported traders saw about a 95.7 percent chance of a 25-basis-point rise, which lifts the dollar and takes demand away from gold, which pays no interest.
Gold is one of Pakistan’s imported goods, so a lower world price trims the import bill, although the trade deficit was revised to $4.13 billion in October. Households also hold gold as protection against the rupee and rising prices, at a time when Pakistan owes Rs90.98 trillion in public debt.
Investors have taken over the bazaar
The most striking change is who is buying. Dawn reported from Karachi that there are now more buyers than sellers, and that investors, not jewellery buyers, are setting the pace. All Karachi Jewellers and Manufacturers Association President Haseen Qureishi confirmed that investors outnumber jewellery buyers. Shops that stood empty when a tola reached about Rs585,000 are busy again, and some buyers who had switched to silver or artificial jewellery at the peak are back.
The investors buying bars are betting the price will rise again, and Hyderi Market traders say they expect the rate to go up from here. But the market is split down the middle. Qureishi said about 50 percent of investors are still holding back, waiting for a further fall of Rs40,000 to Rs50,000 a tola, which would take the rate to between Rs326,336 and Rs336,336. One half is buying the dip, the other half is waiting.
What happens next
What happens next depends on the US Federal Reserve. Its December decision will set the direction for the dollar, and the dollar will set the direction for gold. For a buyer, the lesson is simple. Do not judge the price from the board alone. Ask the premium on the bar before paying, compare it across two or three shops, and count it in the total cost, because a Rs30,000 premium wipes out more than the whole two-day fall of Rs18,900. For bars, the bargain only becomes real when the premium comes down. Watch the USD to PKR exchange rate today too, because a weaker rupee would push local gold up even if the world price stays flat. For more business and economy news from Pakistan, follow PakMirror.
