Pakistan plans to import 800,000 more tons of wheat, but the new order still leaves the country well short of the grain it needs. A committee led by Deputy Prime Minister Ishaq Dar recommended the extra imports on Saturday 21 November, after the first imports failed to cut flour prices. A 20kg flour bag now costs up to Rs3,600 in Karachi, Hyderabad, Islamabad and Bannu. It is not yet an approval, and no date or source country has been announced. Even if approved in full, total imports would reach 1.55 million tons, only about half of the three million tons traders say is needed before the next harvest.
The recommendation, and what it does not decide
Dar chaired two meetings in Islamabad on Saturday, one on the proposed export of surplus sugar and one on the availability and price stability of essential food items, including wheat. The wheat meeting reviewed stocks and supply routes, then recommended up to 800,000 more metric tons to keep stocks sufficient at reasonable prices. The official statements did not say when the proposal would go for formal approval, or where the grain would come from. Dar told departments to enforce price stability and curb profiteering. The same day, Pakistan approved sugar exports of 416,000 tonnes, the third such permission in four months.
The first imports barely moved the price
The new recommendation admits the first round of imports did not work as promised. The first cargo of 51,000 tons reached Karachi Port on 28 October, and more than 100,000 tons have arrived since late October. Open-market wheat fell from Rs140 to Rs130 a kilo after the first ship docked, then rose straight back to Rs140. Retailers added Rs10 a kilo in mid-November, taking No. 2.5 flour to Rs180 a kilo and fine flour to Rs200 in Karachi. Bureau of Statistics data for 19 November put the national average 20kg bag at Rs2,968.92, about 38 percent above a year earlier. In Lahore the bag rose Rs334 in a week to Rs3,467.
The gap the new order cannot close
The arithmetic is the story. The government approved 750,000 tons of imports in September, as the first phase of a one million-ton programme. Add the new 800,000 tons and the total is 1.55 million tons. Traders say Pakistan needs at least three million tons until the next crop reaches markets between March and May 2027, so 1.55 million tons still leaves about 1.45 million tons missing. Pakistan produced 29.61 million tons of wheat in the last financial year, up 4.3 percent from 28.40 million tons, according to the Economic Survey. Annual demand runs at 31 to 32 million tons, so production alone falls short by 1.39 to 2.39 million tons. Punjab’s agriculture department puts the shortfall at 2.5 million tons; the market estimate runs to three to four million tons.
Karachi shows the distribution is failing too
More wheat will not help if grain already here cannot reach the mills. In Karachi, millers offer flour from government wheat at Rs146 a kilo, while the Sindh government wants Rs140 a kilo, and the two sides have not agreed. Karachi mills lift imported wheat directly from the port, but mills in interior Sindh have not received government wheat despite release permits. The Flour Mills Association warns the supply gap in Sindh is widening, and mills have threatened to shut down. Punjab fixed a 10kg flour bag at Rs1,275 under its own scheme, but that is a provincial price, and it has not stopped prices rising elsewhere. An NDMA drought alert for Sindh and Balochistan warns of dry conditions in the wheat-growing south.
The shortage started at procurement
The shortage began at procurement, months ago. A Dawn analysis reported Punjab’s aggregator model bought only 160,000 tons against a three million-ton target, and nine of 11 companies could not even start buying. The province is now releasing about 3,500 tons of wheat a day, against a traditional supply of around 25,000 tons. Former finance minister Miftah Ismail has criticised the handling, saying the government waited too long, did not import enough, and routed purchases through the Trading Corporation of Pakistan instead of letting private traders bring in wheat. He says farmers got under Rs65 a kilo at harvest; wheat now fetches Rs155 to Rs157 in Karachi.
What to watch next
Three tests will show whether it changes anything. First, whether it gets formal approval, and how fast. Second, whether the Trading Corporation of Pakistan buys it again or private traders are allowed in, as the trade has asked since May. Third, whether the Karachi deadlock is settled at Rs140 or Rs146 a kilo. Until then, the 800,000 tons is a recommendation on paper, and the Rs3,600 flour bag is the reality. Read more business and economy news from Pakistan.
