The Federal Constitutional Court has struck down the infrastructure cess charged by Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, ending a tax fight that began in 1994. A two-member bench headed by Chief Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan announced it on Thursday 19 November, declaring both cess Acts unconstitutional. The ruling wipes out a tax that raised about Rs160 billion in Sindh in one year, and it undercuts a February settlement covering Rs350 billion of disputed cess.
A 32-year fight, from 1994 to the FCC
Sindh first imposed the levy in 1994, and the 2017 Act gave it its current form: a cess on goods entering or leaving Sindh from abroad, collected through customs. The Sindh High Court upheld it on 4 June 2021. Khyber Pakhtunkhwa followed with its own 2022 Act and raised the rate from 1 percent to 2 percent in 2024; the Peshawar High Court dismissed 157 petitions against it on 14 November 2025. In all, 568 importers, exporters and industrialists appealed to the Federal Constitutional Court.
The case turned on who may tax trade. The Attorney General argued that imports and exports across customs frontiers belong exclusively to Parliament under Article 142(a) with Entries 27 and 43 of the Federal Legislative List. FBR counsel Hafiz Ehsaan Ahmad Khokhar called the cess an export duty in effect, which even the federal government may not impose, since Section 18(2) of the Customs Act 1969 bars export duty. The provinces called it a charge for roads and infrastructure under Article 142(c). The court rejected that.
The money: Rs160 billion a year, Rs438 million a day
Former FPCCI vice president Khurram Ijaz said Sindh collected Rs160 billion in cess in fiscal year 2024-25 and about Rs800 billion over five years, or about Rs438 million every day. The rate was 1.85 percent of the value of goods until February 2026, when Sindh cut it to between 0.80 and 0.85 percent and abolished it on the export facilitation scheme. FPCCI president Atif Ikram Sheikh said the cut would save businesses about $700 million a year, worth roughly Rs194 billion at the current USD to PKR exchange rate today. By PakMirror arithmetic, Rs160 billion at the old rate implies goods worth about Rs8.6 trillion passed through the levy each year, so the cess was still worth about Rs70 billion a year at the new rate.
The settlement the ruling just broke
Nine months earlier, traders and Sindh had agreed to settle. FPCCI senior vice president Saquib Fayyaz Magoon said about Rs350 billion of cess was tied up in litigation, and under the February deal traders who withdrew their cases would pay 15 percent by 31 July 2026, 15 percent by 31 October 2026 and 15 percent by 31 July 2027, with the remaining 55 percent spread over 12 years from 2028 to 2040. That meant about Rs157.5 billion in 18 months, then about Rs16 billion a year. The whole plan assumed the cess was lawful. Now the law itself is void, which raises two questions: whether instalments already paid or due still stand, and whether traders can claim back money paid under a law that never had constitutional force. Sindh’s separate claim of about Rs180 billion from oil importers since 2021 is caught too: in October 2025 it demanded bank guarantees from PSO and other oil marketers before releasing cargoes.
What happens next
The short order answers the constitutional question, but the detailed judgment is still to come. It will decide what happens to the money already collected and whether the provinces ask the court to review the decision. For Sindh, that is a revenue hole of roughly Rs70 billion a year. The court has said nothing yet about refunds, and neither province has announced a review. Ijaz pointed out that about Rs800 billion was collected in five years while Karachi’s roads and drains still fail after one spell of rain, which is why traders resented paying for infrastructure that never arrived.
What it means for prices
The FBR’s own counsel told the court the levy raised production costs and made Pakistani goods less competitive abroad, so removing it should cut business costs. For small exporters the relief matters twice over, since trade and credit costs hit the same thin margins, and SME lending must grow five times faster to reach Rs2 trillion by 2028. Cheaper imports should also help inflation, which the State Bank expects to ease into its 5 to 7 percent target range this fiscal year. Nothing forces an importer to cut prices, and the cess was only one line in the landed cost, alongside freight, duties and the exchange rate. The detailed judgment must still settle refunds. Until then, traders moving goods through Karachi and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa have one certainty: the cess is gone. More in our Business and Economy news.
