Container ships and stacked shipping containers at a busy seaport terminal under a clear sky, with gantry cranes loading cargo

Court Scraps the Infrastructure Cess, but the Rs43 Billion Question Is Who Gets Paid Back

Ali Raza
6 Min Read
Disclosure:This article is based on publicly available information and professional analysis. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the content reflects the author's views and does not constitute financial, legal, or investment advice. Readers are encouraged to consult relevant experts before making decisions.

The Federal Constitutional Court has struck down the infrastructure cess charged by Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, ending a tax fight that began in 1994. The ruling wipes out a levy on goods moving through Karachi’s ports and across provincial borders, and it puts about Rs43 billion of company liabilities in play. But the judgment answers the constitutional question and leaves the money question open. Nobody yet knows who gets paid back, how much, or how Sindh replaces the revenue.

What the court decided

A two-member bench headed by Chief Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan and Justice Aamer Farooq announced the reserved judgment on Thursday 19 November. It heard 568 appeals and set aside the decisions of the Sindh High Court and the Peshawar High Court. The laws at issue were the Sindh Infrastructure Cess Act, 2017, and the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Infrastructure Development Cess Act, 2022. The court held that the cess fell outside provincial powers, because it worked as a customs duty, charged on goods crossing borders and collected at customs clearance, a federal subject.

The Rs43 billion on company books

Arif Habib Limited says 11 listed companies carry outstanding cess liabilities of Rs42.9 billion, which the ruling could reverse. Fauji Fertilizer Company carries the largest exposure at Rs11.61 billion, about 27% of the total, followed by Indus Motor Company at Rs4.96 billion and Honda Atlas Cars at Rs4.85 billion. Indus Motor gains most per share at Rs47.37, followed by Honda Atlas at Rs25.47. Reversing the liabilities could save the 11 companies about Rs5.15 billion a year in financing costs, assuming a 12% interest rate. The KSE-100 staged a 478-point rebound in November, and the cess ruling gives investors another reason to watch their results.

Settled and unsettled firms face different maths

Not every company is in the same position. JS Global says companies fall into two groups, depending on whether they settled with Sindh in February 2026. Those that did not settle, including Nishat Mills, Fauji Fertilizer Company and Service Long March, hold liabilities of about Rs15.8 billion, which they are now expected to reverse. Companies that did settle, including Engro Holdings, International Steels and Engro Fertilizers, are expected to reverse remaining provisions worth about Rs21.9 billion. Arif Habib Limited reports that the settling companies have already booked Rs16.7 billion as present value gains, so part is already booked. The Sindh High Court had upheld the Act in June 2021, but the Supreme Court suspended it that September, so companies kept provisions on their books and the reversal now appears as a gain, not a cash refund.

The rate that climbed from 1% to 1.85%

Sindh first introduced the cess in 1994 as a 1% charge on the cost and freight value of goods. It rose to 1.25%, then to 1.85% from July 2024, a rate 85% higher than the original 1%. In February 2026, Sindh cut the rate to 0.85% for companies that settled, and to 0.80% for companies without litigation, with instalments running until 2040. Khyber Pakhtunkhwa raised its own rate to 2% in 2024. The cess was a major revenue stream for Sindh: it generated more than Rs1.5 trillion over the past five years, a Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry executive committee member says, about Rs300 billion a year on average. The cess was charged on the cost and freight value of imported goods, so its size also moved with the USD to PKR exchange rate today, and October’s trade gap widened to $3.88 billion as imports kept climbing.

Two questions the ruling has not answered

The first unanswered question is refunds. The court has declared the laws unconstitutional, but it has not yet said whether traders who paid the cess can claim the money back. The second question is what replaces the revenue. Sindh argued that the money funds infrastructure and roads. The court rejected that argument, holding that a province cannot build a fiscal barrier inside the national trading system under an infrastructure label. But the ruling does not say how Sindh, or Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, should fill the gap, and neither province has yet announced a replacement.

What happens next

Three things will decide how much of the Rs43 billion turns into gains. First, the detailed judgment, which may address refunds and the February 2026 settlements. Second, whether the provinces file review petitions, which Arif Habib Limited flags as a real possibility. Third, what companies do in their next quarterly accounts, since most will wait for the detailed judgment before reversing liabilities. For businesses, the message is that the tax is gone, but the money is not yet in hand. For the provinces, a levy which raised about Rs300 billion a year has to be replaced. More business and economy news from Pakistan will follow as the detailed judgment arrives.

Share This Article
Follow:
Ali Raza is a Pakistani journalist and digital news writer with over five years of experience covering Pakistan's political landscape, international affairs, sports, and emerging technology. He has reported on major national events including general elections, military developments, and Pakistan's evolving economic policies. Ali contributes to PakMirror with a commitment to accurate, fast, and reader-first reporting that keeps Pakistanis informed on the stories that matter most.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *