Pakistan’s first nationwide study of 2,000 apparently healthy adults has found heart disease already building in the arteries of one in four of them, even though none had any symptoms. The PAK-SEHAT study, presented on Saturday at the 55th CardioCon in Islamabad, found 78 percent of participants were obese, 33 percent had high blood pressure, 22 percent had diabetes and another 23 percent were prediabetic, and calcium was found in the coronary arteries of 26 percent. The average participant was only 39 years old.
The scan found what a normal checkup misses
The study did not rely on how the participants felt. Each person had blood tests, a neck artery ultrasound and a coronary CT scan of the heart’s arteries. Dr Bashir Hanif, the study’s principal investigator, told the conference that calcium was found in the coronary arteries of 26 percent of participants, and that conventional clinical risk assessments could underestimate how much disease was actually present.
The basic readings tell the same story. Only 34 percent of participants had optimal blood pressure, only 55 percent had optimal blood glucose, and only 23 percent had optimal cholesterol, according to a summary of the findings by Dr Nauman Naseer, one of the study investigators. About one in 12 had significant coronary calcification, a calcium score above 100, which marks a heavier burden of plaque.
The risks pile up in the same people
The danger is not one bad number on its own. Hanif told the conference that the risk factors did not occur in isolation: high blood pressure, unhealthy cholesterol, obesity and diabetes frequently coexisted in the same individuals, and the more risk factors a person carried, the more silent atherosclerosis the scans found. Obesity, defined using the Asian body mass index cut-off of 25, was found in 81 percent of the women and 74 percent of the men. A further 32 percent reported a family history of premature coronary heart disease, and 68 percent had low levels of good HDL cholesterol.
Many participants did not even know they were at risk. At an earlier presentation of the study’s preliminary findings, Hanif reported that 42 percent were found to have undiagnosed high blood pressure and 23 percent had undiagnosed diabetes. The diabetes figures sit on top of a national problem: one in three adults in Pakistan has diabetes, and 9.3 million do not know it.
Ten to fifteen years early
The study also sharpens a fact Pakistani doctors have warned about for years: heart disease arrives much earlier here than in the West. Dr Khurram Nasir, the co-principal investigator at Houston Methodist, said heart disease appeared to develop 10 to 15 years earlier among Pakistanis than in other populations, and that being a man aged 35 or above could itself be a risk factor. He called the study a gold mine of data for a population largely invisible in global medical research.
An older Karachi survey points the same way. A study of 320 adults aged 40 and above in Karachi found coronary artery disease in 26.9 percent of them, almost the same share the new scans found in younger people with no symptoms at all, though it measured disease differently. The new study also looks beyond the usual suspects, examining environmental contributors including air and water quality, pollution levels and regional dietary habits. Lahore’s air is still eight times the safe limit.
What happens next: a Pakistani risk score
PAK-SEHAT is a prospective cohort study, which means the work is only beginning. The 2,000 participants, men aged 35 to 60 and women aged 35 to 65 recruited from all four provinces and Islamabad through eight centres, will be followed up over five years, with repeat scans to track how the plaque in their arteries progresses. Genome sequencing will look for genetic vulnerabilities in South Asians.
The point of all that follow-up is practical. Hanif has argued that Pakistan needs its own cardiovascular risk score, because the current American models were designed for older populations and do not account well for people under 40. The study has been called Pakistan’s mini Framingham, after the landmark American heart study, and it is funded by Getz Pharma with nearly Rs1.4 billion, according to an earlier report on the project.
For now, the study’s message is simple and uncomfortable: feeling fine is not proof of a healthy heart. A third of apparently healthy adults in this study already had high blood pressure, more than one in five already had diabetes, and one in four already carried calcium in their coronary arteries. The findings give new weight to hypertension awareness efforts in Pakistan, and the researchers’ answer is to find the risk before the symptom. Read more health news from Pakistan in our Health section.
