A container ship being loaded with colourful shipping containers at a busy seaport at dusk, with tall gantry cranes and stacks of containers in the foreground

IMF Warns Pakistan’s Buffers Are Thin, and the First-Quarter Numbers Show Why

Ali Raza
6 Min Read
Disclosure:This article is based on publicly available information and professional analysis. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the content reflects the author's views and does not constitute financial, legal, or investment advice. Readers are encouraged to consult relevant experts before making decisions.

Pakistan has regained macroeconomic stability, but the IMF’s representative in Islamabad says the recovery stands on thin buffers. At the 6th Pakistan Prosperity Forum on Thursday, IMF Resident Representative Mahir Binici warned that the fiscal position could weaken as imports rise and remittances slow. “Pakistan’s recovery continues, but the outlook remains exposed to external shocks,” he said. “Stabilisation is necessary, but not sufficient.”

The warning comes weeks before the IMF board decides on about $1.2 billion in further financing. The question nobody at the forum would answer is what happens when the current $7 billion programme ends in September 2027.

A $2 billion gap in the forecasts

The Fund’s own numbers explain the caution: its October Regional Economic Outlook puts Pakistan’s current account deficit at about 1 percent of GDP, roughly $4.5 billion. The government’s projection is about $2.5 billion, so the IMF expects a deficit about 80 percent larger.

The same report puts Pakistan’s gross external financing needs at 22 to 25 percent of GDP, far above peer economies. The country must raise or roll over roughly a quarter of its annual output every year. The IMF kept its growth forecast at 3.5 percent, below the government’s target of 4 percent, and Binici said inflation was expected to stay around 8 percent in FY27.

What the first quarter already shows

State Bank data for July to September, the first quarter of FY27, shows the pattern Binici warned about. The current account deficit was $874 million, wider than the $755 million of the same quarter last year. Goods exports rose 7.7 percent to about $8.5 billion, but goods imports rose 14.3 percent to about $17.8 billion. The goods gap widened from about $7.71 billion to about $9.33 billion, about $1.63 billion wider in one quarter, as imports added about $2.23 billion while exports added only about $0.60 billion.

What kept the deficit small was remittances: about $10.88 billion in the quarter, up 14 percent on a year earlier, adding about $1.34 billion that covered most of the widening trade gap. The pressure did not stop there: October’s trade gap widened to $3.88 billion. Yet the overall balance of payments still showed a $3.1 billion surplus, against a deficit of $274 million a year earlier. That surplus came from financing, not trade: a $3 billion Eurobond issue and about $2.9 billion of portfolio inflows. Reserves stood at about $21.5 billion, roughly three months of import cover. October’s current account did show a small $39 million surplus in revised data, but one month does not change the trend.

A growth ceiling of 3.8 percent

The forum also heard why faster growth is hard. Louie Dane of the British High Commission said Asian Development Bank research put Pakistan’s growth ceiling at around 3.8 percent, beyond which imports outpace exports. The IMF’s own forecast is 3.5 percent, leaving only about 0.3 points of headroom.

Binici put it plainly. Real per capita income is rising by only about 1.6 percent a year, investment remains below 13 percent of GDP, and exports have slipped to roughly 10 percent of GDP. The State Bank’s annual report for FY27 made a similar point. His five priorities were tax reform, trade and exchange-rate reform, energy efficiency, governance and state-owned enterprise reform, and a better business environment.

The question nobody answered

The most telling moment was what Binici would not say. Asked about a fresh IMF programme after the current arrangement expires, he did not respond, and Minister of State for Finance Bilal Azhar Kayani evaded the question too. The silence matters because the programme ends in September 2027, and Pakistan has not said what replaces it.

Before that comes the nearer test. Pakistan and the IMF reached a staff-level agreement in October, and board approval would release about $1.2 billion, roughly $1 billion under the Extended Fund Facility and $200 million under the Resilience and Sustainability Facility. But no date has yet appeared on the IMF board’s calendar. Some reports put the meeting in late November and others in December, with the sugar deregulation the Fund has demanded still hanging over it.

What happens next

For households, the test is whether remittances keep growing fast enough to cover an import bill rising faster than exports. October remittances hit $3.89 billion and covered the whole trade gap, but the Fund’s message is that this cover cannot be taken for granted.

Three things will show whether the warning was early or on time: the IMF board meeting; the next trade and current account figures; and the government’s answer to what comes after September 2027. Until then, the recovery is real but narrow, and the buffers behind it are, in Binici’s own word, moderate. For the latest business and economy news from Pakistan, watch imports, remittances and reserves.

Share This Article
Follow:
Ali Raza is a Pakistani journalist and digital news writer with over five years of experience covering Pakistan's political landscape, international affairs, sports, and emerging technology. He has reported on major national events including general elections, military developments, and Pakistan's evolving economic policies. Ali contributes to PakMirror with a commitment to accurate, fast, and reader-first reporting that keeps Pakistanis informed on the stories that matter most.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *