The Gilgit-Baltistan Election Commission declared Pakistan Peoples Party candidate Attaullah Shah the winner of the GBA-16 Diamer-II seat on Monday night, ending a dispute that has run for more than five months. The consolidated result, Form 49, gave Shah 6,758 votes against 6,673 for the Istehkam-i-Pakistan Party’s Imam Malik, a margin of 85 out of 13,431 cast.
The result came from a re-poll at just three polling stations, in Thor, Sarri and Gichi, where 2,780 voters were registered. Voting ran from 8am to 5pm on Sunday, 15 November, but the commission issued the consolidated result more than 24 hours after polling ended. Supporters of both parties blocked the Karakoram Highway for 10 hours, and tensions eased only once the commission named the winner, Dawn reported.
A seat that changed hands three times
It began on polling day, 7 June. The first count, Form 47, put Malik ahead by 24 votes, 6,320 against 6,296 for Shah, because the returning officer had not counted postal ballots. Shah petitioned the tribunal: the postal votes, 473 for him against 180 for Malik, would have put him ahead, and June protesters claimed Form 48 showed him winning by 269 votes.
The commission ordered re-polling at three stations, and protests blocking the Karakoram Highway ran for a third day on 10 June. Malik was nevertheless notified as the returned candidate on 19 June and later joined the IPP.
In September the tribunal suspended Malik’s membership and ordered the postal ballots counted. The recount changed the result: on 14 September Shah was declared the winner with 6,618 votes, a margin of just 13, and days later the Supreme Appellate Court dismissed Malik’s appeal.
Malik then challenged the results at the three stations. The tribunal accepted his plea, suspended Shah’s membership on 6 November and ordered a re-poll within 12 days. Shah challenged the order in the Chief Court, but a bench led by Chief Judge Ali Baig upheld it, and the vote went ahead.
What the re-poll actually changed
The re-poll moved the margin more than the September recount. Against the September Form 49, Shah gained 140 votes and Malik 68, so the margin widened from 13 to 85. Both gained because the fresh vote replaced the old count, and Shah gained more of the new votes.
The margin is remarkable: 85 votes out of 13,431, about six in every thousand. The three stations that decided it hold 2,780 registered voters, and turnout has not been published. In June the same three stations held the whole result back, and in November they changed it again.
The result settles only so much. The seat has already been overturned twice by tribunal orders, and Malik can challenge again. Until the notification is issued, the winner is whoever holds the latest Form 49.
A result that arrived after a highway blockade
Sunday’s vote was not quiet. Polling officer Dr Maria told Dawn that Malik had allegedly slapped a female polling officer at the Sarai station. After polling closed, Shah’s supporters took to the streets in Chilas and Gilgit, saying ballot boxes had been taken from a women’s station. They blocked the Karakoram Highway near Chilas and burnt tyres outside the Gilgit-Baltistan Assembly hall.
Gilgit-Baltistan Police then registered a terrorism case over polling material taken from the Wara station, the Express Tribune reported. The report did not name those charged. Chief Election Commissioner Raja Shahbaz Khan said an investigation was under way and the commission had provided foolproof security.
The delay fed the standoff. Dawn reported that the result came more than 24 hours after polling ended, keeping the dispute alive through the day. Once Shah was named the winner on Monday night, the blockade ended and traffic on the Karakoram Highway began moving again. Days earlier, eleven people were killed when a van fell into a river in Ghizer.
What happens next
Shah now returns to a seat he has held, lost and won again in five months. The PPP, which won 11 of 24 seats in June on unofficial figures, keeps a seat it first won only after the postal count in September. Local reporting said the PML-N backed Malik, so the result also measures the PPP’s standing in Diamer against a rival backed by the IPP and the PML-N.
The next test is administrative. Gilgit-Baltistan votes in local government polls on 5 December, and the machinery that took more than a day over three stations will run a far larger vote. Parliament’s electoral reforms committee has yet to name its members, so no new rules govern that vote. For Diamer, the question is narrower: whether Malik accepts an 85-vote defeat or takes the seat back to the tribunal for a third time.
More national news from Pakistan is available on PakMirror’s National News pages.
