The MQM-P wants Pakistan to vote on new provinces in December. On Tuesday, its leader Dr Farooq Sattar demanded a December referendum under Article 48(6) of the Constitution. Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari warned that any forced division of Sindh would bring bloodshed to Karachi and Hyderabad, while Information Minister Attaullah Tarar called it a constitutional way to ask the people. But two different referendums are being talked about, neither has a legal road, and a December vote needs five things to happen in six weeks, none of which has started.
What happened on Tuesday
Sattar spoke at the MQM-P headquarters in Bahadurabad, Karachi. He said it should be held in December, before 2027 begins, so the people decide the country’s future administrative structure.
On Sunday, Health Minister Mustafa Kamal told party workers that December would be crucial and a referendum would be held, while party chairman Khalid Maqbool Siddiqui urged Karachi residents to back the party’s proposed ‘Haqiqi Referendum’ on Shahrah-e-Faisal.
Bilawal answered at the Karachi Press Club. He said the PPP backed new provinces in line with public wishes, the Constitution and the law, but would resist any decision imposed by force. He said the Sindh Assembly had stated its position ‘not once, but ten times’, and that neither he nor the president had been consulted. The cabinet had not discussed the proposal, let alone parliament.
Tarar replied the same evening, saying a referendum was part of the Constitution and that no agenda could be imposed without the will of the people. But the prime minister’s adviser Rana Sanaullah said on Geo News that the debate had not entered parliament and provinces would be created only through consensus.
Two referendums, not one
Two different votes are being described as one referendum. The official route runs through Article 48(6), which lets the prime minister refer a matter of national importance to a referendum once a joint sitting of parliament approves it. No joint sitting has been called, no question has been published, and Pakistan has no standing referendum law.
The second vote is the MQM-P’s own ‘Haqiqi Referendum’, a party-organised show of support planned for Shahrah-e-Faisal. It is a demonstration, not a decision, with no legal force and no power to bind parliament, the Sindh Assembly or the Election Commission. Until the party says which of the two it means by December, the deadline has no fixed object.
The December countdown
December begins in thirteen days. For an official referendum before 2027, the cabinet would have to discuss the proposal, which it has not; a joint sitting would have to approve the vote; a referendum law would have to be created; the question and polling machinery would have to be settled; and even a Yes vote would change nothing by itself.
Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi proposed a referendum on new provinces last week, saying he would accept the result. A meeting between President Asif Ali Zardari and Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif in Lahore on 14 November produced three different accounts of what was decided about new provinces, and none of them exists on paper.
Creating a province needs an amendment under Article 239, passed by two-thirds of both houses: 224 of 336 National Assembly members and 64 of 96 senators. Where it alters a province’s limits, Article 239(4) requires the affected assembly to approve it first by two-thirds of its total membership, 112 of 168 for Sindh. The Sindh Assembly rejected any division in a resolution on 3 September, and Sindh minister Sharjeel Memon said on Monday that a referendum has no legal standing. The map under discussion would split Punjab into four provinces, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan into three each, and Sindh into two. The obstacles run further: a 28th Amendment would also have to settle the Senate’s size and a new NFC Award.
The numbers that decide it
Public opinion is not the obstacle. A survey of 5,000 people by the Meridian National Barometer in 2026 found 77 per cent support for more provinces, up from 54 per cent in 2022. A referendum can measure opinion; it cannot replace parliament or an assembly’s consent. Bilawal estimated the outstanding provincial share from the petroleum levy at about Rs1.7 trillion. Yet the provinces sat on a combined Rs600bn surplus in the first quarter while sending the Centre only Rs57bn. In 2012, the National Assembly voted for a Janoobi Punjab province and asked the Punjab Assembly to move an amendment. It never did.
What happens next
December will now test which referendum the MQM-P means. A Shahrah-e-Faisal vote would demonstrate support in Karachi, not decide the map. The next markers are a joint sitting and a 28th Amendment. Until the coalition agrees on the route, the December referendum remains a date without a road.
