Exterior of a courthouse building in Pakistan with the national flag flying under a clear sky

HRCP Warned of an Assault on Democracy. A Day Later, the Court Gave Back Part of What It Froze

Ali Raza
6 Min Read
Disclosure:This article is based on publicly available information and professional analysis. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the content reflects the author's views and does not constitute financial, legal, or investment advice. Readers are encouraged to consult relevant experts before making decisions.

The Human Rights Commission of Pakistan closed its 40th annual general meeting on 15 November with a stark warning: constitutional democracy and fundamental rights face what it called an escalating assault across the country. A day later, the Federal Constitutional Court narrowed the very order it had criticised, letting the Peshawar High Court hear most writ petitions again. The warning still stands: what the court gave back on Monday is only part of what it froze on 5 November.

What the commission said

Issued in Lahore by chairperson Asad Iqbal Butt, the statement lists the damage. Freedom of expression, it says, is being dismantled through censorship, surveillance, restrictive regulations and the abuse of criminal laws. The ten-year sentences handed down in October to human rights lawyers Imaan Mazari-Hazir and Hadi Chattha are, in its words, a chilling example of how anyone exercising constitutional rights can be targeted.

Enforced disappearances remain, it says, a grave violation of liberty and due process. It names three detained activists, Mahrang Baloch, Ali Wazir and Idris Khattak, and demands that all detainees be produced before competent courts, arbitrary detention powers under the Anti-Terrorism Act be repealed, internment centres abolished and the ban on the Jammu Kashmir Joint Awami Action Committee in Azad Jammu and Kashmir lifted.

The court gave back part of what it froze

The commission’s criticism of the court was written before Monday’s hearing. Its statement says the court’s intervention restricting the Peshawar High Court’s jurisdiction further undermines access to justice and judicial independence. On Monday, a bench led by Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan narrowed the 5 November order, so the high court can hear Article 199 petitions again except for the categories the order was about. That answers one part of the commission’s complaint, and only one part. The court narrowed its own 5 November stay order, but the rest of the freeze is untouched.

The challenges to emergency and governor’s rule stay frozen, as do the cases of people detained under Section 3 of the Maintenance of Public Order Ordinance. The release orders for 28 PTI workers stay without effect. About 105 petitions were struck from the Peshawar High Court’s cause list after the freeze, and no review board has been formed in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa to hear detention cases. The province’s advocate general told the court one would come after three months, around mid-February 2027. Until then, a detained worker has neither the high court nor the review board to turn to.

A warning repeated, not a new one

On 25 October it demanded an end to emergency and governor’s rule in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, calling the detention of the province’s elected chief executive a grave affront to democratic norms. It warned then that governing by emergency rather than consensus could irretrievably weaken Pakistan’s democracy. The new statement repeats the demand and adds the wider picture: the 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments, it says, have seriously undermined judicial independence and institutional checks and balances. It calls for both amendments to be reviewed, for lifetime immunity for public officeholders to be withdrawn and for military trials of civilians to end.

It also sets a condition on the debate over new provinces: they must not undermine Pakistan’s federal structure or come at the expense of stronger local governments, and any further amendment must rest on cross-party consensus.

Balochistan, and the trade the commission wants restored

On Balochistan, it calls for an open national debate and for cross-border trade to be restored to protect local livelihoods. Pomegranates have roughly doubled in price in Quetta while prices have crashed in Kandahar, where growers cannot move their fruit. The same closure makes fruit dearer for Pakistani shoppers and cheaper for Afghan growers, and livelihoods on both sides pay.

It closes with the groups it says are most exposed: religious minorities facing targeted violence, discrimination and blasphemy-related persecution, including attacks on Ahmadiyya places of worship and a mob attack on a Christian doctor in Sheikhupura, and women, transgender persons and other marginalised communities whose rights cannot remain promises on paper. It wants the National Commission for Minorities set up without delay, and accountability for those inciting violence or forcing conversions. On the economy, it says austerity and weak social protection burden low-income households most, and calls for living wages, decent work and essential public services.

What to watch next

The Peshawar High Court’s administrative committee has not lifted its 6 November directive, so the first test is whether the docket actually reopens in practice. The review board is not expected before around mid-February 2027. Governor’s rule, imposed on 11 October, reaches its six-month limit on 11 April 2027. The statement will be measured against those dates, not against the words of one hearing. More national news from Pakistan follows the same file as it develops.

Share This Article
Follow:
Ali Raza is a Pakistani journalist and digital news writer with over five years of experience covering Pakistan's political landscape, international affairs, sports, and emerging technology. He has reported on major national events including general elections, military developments, and Pakistan's evolving economic policies. Ali contributes to PakMirror with a commitment to accurate, fast, and reader-first reporting that keeps Pakistanis informed on the stories that matter most.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *